Better leads → More sales in 2025: How to analyze leads to improve marketing performance

by

CallRail
X or Twitter icon
LinkedIn icon
Facebook icon
X or Twitter icon
LinkedIn icon
Facebook icon

In a recent webinar, we uncovered insights from 1.1 million leads to explore exactly how your business can improve lead generation, refine marketing strategies, and increase ROI.

Here are some of the most crucial insights.

Key challenges in lead generation

  • Limited visibility into high-performing channels: Many businesses struggle to identify which marketing channels deliver the most qualified leads.
  • Missed insights in lead data: Everyday call insights hold valuable information, but it often goes unnoticed or underutilized.
  • Difficulty optimizing marketing ROI: Without actionable insights, businesses find it challenging to maximize return on investment (ROI) for marketing campaigns, especially with paid channels like PPC.

Top channels driving conversions

When it comes to lead generation, three key channels consistently drive conversions across all industries:


  • Google Ads: Accounts for 37% of leads.
  • Google My Business (GMB): Accounts for  23% of leads.
  • Organic Traffic: Accounts for  22% of leads.
Three circles show marketing channel percentages: 37% Google Ads, 23% Google My Business, 22% Organic Search.

Transcribed Text:

37% Google Ads 23% Google My Business 22% Organic Search

While these channels are consistently effective, their impact can vary from industry to industry. For example, some sectors may see better results from local search (GMB), while others find that paid search or organic traffic delivers the highest ROI.

See below for the channels driving the most calls by industry:

3D stacked bar chart showing lead sources by industry with a color-coded legend.

Transcribed Text:

% OF LEADS 

REAL ESTATE INVESTMENT
10% direct traffic
20% organic search
5% Google My Business
45% Google ads
REAL ESTATE INDUSTRY
22% organic search
25% Google My Business
30% Google ads
LEGAL INDUSTRY
21% organic search
25% Google My Business
45% Google ads
HOME SERVICES 
20% organic search
21% Google My Business
45% Google ads
HEALTHCARE INDUSTRY
25% organic search
25% Google My Business
37% Google ads
FINANCIAL SERVICES
25% organic search
15% Google My Business
48% Google ads
AUTOMOTIVE INDUSTRY
18% organic search
36% Google My Business
34% Google ads

Action item: Refine your marketing strategy based on insights. Focus on the channels that deliver the best results for your industry and adjust when necessary.

Missed calls are missed opportunities

One critical insight from our research is that inbound calls are among the most valuable sources of leads. Yet, most missed calls result in lost opportunities, as 85% of customers won’t give your business a second chance after you miss their call. This highlights the importance of having the right tools in place to manage calls effectively.

Action items:

  1. Implement automated messaging for missed calls: When a call is missed, tools like CallRail can send an automated text message to the caller, acknowledging the missed call and letting them know someone will be in touch shortly. Maintaining the connection reassures the caller that their inquiry is important and can prevent the lead from moving on to the next business on their list.
  2. Leverage advanced call flows: Tools like CallRail’s advanced call flow system can help reduce missed calls and improve lead follow-up. For instance, you can: Route calls to available team members when someone is busy, use voicemail-to-email transcription for quick responses, or customize call flows to suit your business needs, ensuring every lead is captured and nurtured.

Key channels driving conversions

The top three channels contributing to qualified leads across industries are Google Ads (47%), organic search (23%), and Google My Business (15%).

A donut chart showing traffic sources: 47% Google Ads, 23% Organic Search, 15% Google My Business, and a small "Other" category.

Transcribed Text:

47% Google Ads
23% Organic Search
15% Google My Business
Other

The top channels that lead to the highest return on investment across industries are organic search (78%), paid search (75%), and social ads (70%).

Three circles showing statistics: 78% Organic Search, 75% Paid Search, 70% Social Ads.

Transcribed Text:

78% Organic Search
75% Paid Search
70% Social Ads

The top channels that contributed to the most sales appointments made across industries are Google Ads (36%), Google My Business (32%), and organic search (18%).

Donut chart showing 36% Google Ads, 32% Google My Business, 18% Organic Search, and a small section labeled Other.

Transcribed Text:

32% Google My Business
18% Organic Search
36% Google Ads
Other

Action item: Invest in high-performing channels that drive the highest rate of qualified leads. For example, industries like automotive and real estate see the best results by prioritizing website traffic for lead qualification.

How customers are finding your business

Insights from self-reported attribution reveals how customers discover businesses:

  • Online Search: 38.5% of customers.
  • Returning Customers: 39.5% of customers.
  • Personal Referrals: 15.6% of customers.
  • Direct Mail: 6.2% of customers.
Donut chart showing customer sources: 39.6% Returning Customers, 38.5% Online Search, 15.6% Personal Referral, 6.2% Direct Mail.

Transcribed Text:

38.5% Online Search
15.6% Personal Referral
39.6% Returning Customers
6.2% Direct Mail

Understanding these sources can help your business double down on the strategies that work best for your audience.

Top keywords to optimize your pay-per-click strategy

Aligning your PPC keywords with customer interest is critical to driving that high quality traffic and maximizing the effectiveness of your marketing spend. Using the right keywords ensures your ads reach the right audience, increasing the likelihood of conversions, whether it's for leads, appointments, or sales.

See below for the top performing keywords by industry:

Four blue rectangles list services for Automotive, Home Services, Real Estate Industry, and Real Estate Investment.

Transcribed Text:

AUTOMOTIVE INDUSTRY

We buy junk cars
Sell my car
Mobile mechanic
HOME SERVICES

Garage door repair
Roof repair
Junk removal
AC repair
Plumbers near me
REAL ESTATE INDUSTRY

Searching for apartments
Senior or assisted living
Searching for apartments near me [near X]
REAL ESTATE INVESTMENT

E-waste
Land for sale
Extended stay

Quick tip: Customers increasingly use intent driven queries such as location specific terms like ‘near me’ or industry relevant keywords. Using these localized relevant keywords improves visibility in search results and ensures your ads are seen by customers actively searching for your services.

How call sentiment analysis personalizes your customer experience

You can use call sentiment to track overall customer satisfaction trends to get a general idea of how customers feel about your business. Call sentiment can also spot at-risk leads, such as customers who are expressing frustration or dissatisfaction on a call. Using this information, customer interactions can be more mindful and you can tailor the conversation to the specific needs and wants of each customer.

Action item: Drive conversions with sentiment-driven strategies to personalize the customer’s experience. Use sentiment analysis to get a sense of what the customer needs, their demeanor, and what you can prepare for the next conversation to appropriately address their needs.

Key takeaways

  1. Track calls to measure marketing channel performance: Using call tracking where your calls originate helps you better allocate your marketing budget and focus your efforts on the highest-performing channels.
  2. Leverage AI-powered insights to optimize strategies: Analyzing call insights, sentiment, and keywords allows your business to refine its marketing strategies to align with customer behavior and needs.
  3. Use tools like Convert Assist to convert leads quickly and effectively: While AI helps uncover insights from customer conversations, tools like Convert Assist take it a step further by generating next steps, follow-up messaging, and coaching feedback so that businesses can act on these insights faster and increase conversions.

Data-driven insights are the key to unlocking better lead generation and higher marketing ROI. By focusing on high-performing channels, leveraging call management tools, and refining your marketing strategy based on performance, you can drive growth and capture more qualified leads.

Meet the author

CallRail
Serving more than 200,000 companies worldwide, CallRail is the AI-powered lead intelligence platform that makes it easy for businesses of all sizes to market with confidence.